A must stop along Buffalo's beer trail. Nestled among grain elevators, multi-family homes, and active railroad tracks in Buffalo’s First Ward, McCarthy’s has long been a favorite gathering spot for local workers, firefighters, police officers, and politicians. Over the years, it's expanded offerings to include a diverse selection of craft and regional beers, with Old First Ward Brewing Company now serving over many unique brews.
McCarthy’s is famous for its classic Buffalo fare, including our renowned beef on weck, savory corned beef and cabbage, and mouthwatering fish fry. Proudly featured as one of the 14 stops on the Buffalo Wing Trail, remaining a beloved destination for both locals and visitors craving an authentic taste of Buffalo.
Craft Beer
Wine
Spirits
Cider
Restaurant Menu
Patio
Craft beer to go
Cider to go
Gluten free beer
Non alcoholic beer