"From the moment we were awkwardly greeted to the long 10-minute wait for a server, we hoped the food would be the highlight of our visit. We ordered two of the house pizzas: the Mashed Potato & Bacon and the Portrait of New Haven. Both pizzas arrived hot and generously topped. However, the lack of seasoning and the uneven slicing were notable drawbacks. While the crust was cooked to our preference, the undercarriage was underdone, making it difficult to eat with our hands. Without silverware and with no server checking in on us, we struggled to enjoy our meal. We only saw our server twice: once to take our order and once to process payment. Although this place didn’t quite hit the spot for us, it might appeal to those who prefer minimal attention and decent food."

"the "small" pizza is, in fact, huge. also got an excellent recommendation from the bartender for a beer (zombie something) while I was waiting for my pizza. all in all a great experience. nice space, nice people, great food and drink."

"BAR pizza is truly to die for! Some of the best in New Haven, and that’s saying something!! They have so many different assortments of wood fired pizza, you truly can’t go wrong."

"So far this has been the best pizza in new haven. Pepes is a busy Sally's is too expensive for what you get, here is pricey but much better quality. We got the mashed potatoes and bacon on a red pizza. It was very tasty and the potatoes are a bit strange on a pizza but they worked and were well seasoned."

"Our family loves this place. Is it the best pizza in New Haven? Having tried all of them, it is among the best but hard to name “the” best. It is BY FAR the best for food, drink, service, and AMBIANCE. They have a good selection of beers on tap, a great salad, and great environment."